Initial Comparison of LS and an NSE EOS


Astronomy research
Software instruments
   Stellar equation of states
   EOS with ionization
   EOS for supernovae
   Chemical potentials
   Stellar atmospheres

   Voigt Function
   Jeans escape
   Polytropic stars
   Cold white dwarfs
   Hotter white dwarfs

   Cold neutron stars
   Stellar opacities
   Neutrino energy loss rates
   Ephemeris routines
   Fermi-Dirac functions

   Galactic chemical evolution
   Coating an ellipsoid

   Nuclear reaction networks
   Nuclear statistical equilibrium
   Laminar deflagrations
   CJ detonations
   ZND detonations

   Fitting to conic sections
   Unusual linear algebra
   Derivatives on uneven grids
   Pentadiagonal solver
   Quadratics, Cubics, Quartics

   Supernova light curves
   Exact Riemann solutions
   1D PPM Hydrodynamics
   Verification problems
   Plane - Cube Intersection

   The pendulum


   Zingale's software
   Brown's dStar
   GR1D code
   Iliadis' STARLIB database
   Herwig's NuGRID
   Meyer's NetNuc
Bicycle adventures

AAS Journals
2017 MESA Marketplace
2017 MESA Summer School
2017 ASU+EdX AST111x
Teaching materials
Education and Public Outreach

Contact: F.X.Timmes
my one page vitae,
full vitae,
research statement, and
teaching statement.

Mass fraction of alpha particles:
The abundances of neutrons, protons, and alpha particles is probably the fundamental quantities to focus on as the thermodynamic variables will more-or-less follow the composition.

Alpha wall from NSE (fxt)
Alpha wall from NSE (meyer)
Alpha wall from LS

The differences between the two NSE calculations (fxt and brad meyer) at temperatures of 1012 K is understood; different extrapolations procedures are used for temperatures larger than where the tabulated data runs out. The alpha wall from the LS EOS is shorter, not as thick, and in a a slightly location. The incipient proto-neutron star lives in the lower right where heavy nuclei live. When the shock wave passes the material climbs the alpha wall, ending in the region in the upper left where alpha-particles, neutrons and protons live.

Mass fraction of neutron and protons:

Neutrons from NSE
Neutrons from LS
Protons from NSE
Protons from LS

Since the NSE + stellar EOS and the LS EOS basically agree in the neutron and proton abundances, this might be telling us that the problem isn't in the neutron and proton chemical potentials. The alpha-particle plots above then seem to suggest that the LS EOS isn't quite hitting the right average charge, zbar, in regions where NSE should be a good approximation.

Entropy Differences:

Entropy (LS - NSE)
This plot shows that the LS EOS and the NSE + stellar EOS can differ by as much as 30%. Red contours indicate regions where LS gives more entropy, while black indicates regionsindicate regions where NSE gives more entropy. The green contour at 0% is where they two equations of state agree. Are these 30% differences in the entropy significant in a core-collapse calculation?