44Ti, 60Co & 56Ni
From Supernova Explosions


Astronomy research
  Software Infrastructure:
     My instruments
  White dwarf supernova:
     Remnant metallicities
     Colliding white dwarfs
     Merging white dwarfs
     Ignition conditions
     Metallicity effects
     Central density effects
     Detonation density effects
     Tracer particle burning
     Subsonic burning fronts
     Supersonic burning fronts
     W7 profiles
  Massive star supernova:
     Rotating progenitors
     3D evolution
     26Al & 60Fe
     44Ti, 60Co & 56Ni
     Yields of radionuclides
     Effects of 12C +12C
     SN 1987A light curve
     Constraints on Ni/Fe ratios
     An r-process
     Compact object IMF
     Neutrino HR diagram
     Pulsating white dwarfs
     Pop III with JWST
     Monte Carlo massive stars
     Neutrinos from pre-SN
     Pre-SN variations
     Monte Carlo white dwarfs
     SAGB stars
     Classical novae
     He shell convection
     Presolar grains
     He burn on neutron stars
     BBFH at 40 years
  Chemical Evolution:
     Iron Pseudocarbynes
     Radionuclides in the 2020s
     Hypatia catalog
     Zone models H to Zn
     Mixing ejecta
     γ-rays within 100 Mpc
  Thermodynamics & Networks
     Stellar EOS
     12C(α,γ)16O Rate
     Proton-rich NSE
     Reaction networks
     Bayesian reaction rates
  Verification Problems:
     Validating an astro code
Software instruments
cococubed YouTube
Bicycle adventures
Public Outreach
Education materials

AAS Journals
AAS YouTube
2020 Celebration of Margaret Burbidge
2020 Digital Infrastructure
2021 MESA Marketplace
2021 MESA Summer School
2021 ASU Solar Systems
2021 ASU Energy in Everyday Life

Contact: F.X.Timmes
my one page vitae,
full vitae,
research statement, and
teaching statement.

Observations - (2018)

44Ti Cas A map
Grefenstette et al 2017

44Ti SN 1987A map
Boggs et al 2015
44Ti SN 1987A
Boggs et al 2015

Diehl et al 1998

Oberlack et al 1994
COMPTEL 44Ti Vela map

The light curve of SN 1987A revisited: constraining production masses of radioactive nuclides (2014)
In this effort, we revisit the evidence for the contribution of the long-lived radioactive nuclides $^{44}$Ti, $^{55}$Fe, $^{56}$Co, $^{57}$Co, and $^{60}$Co to the UVOIR light curve of SN 1987A.

Trends in 44Ti and 56Ni from Core-collapse Supernovae (2010)
In this article we compare the yields of 44Ti and 56Ni produced from post-processing the thermodynamic trajectories from three different core-collapse models – Cassiopeia A progenitor, a double shock hypernova progenitor, and a rotating two-dimensional explosion – with the yields from exponential and power-law trajectories.

The peak temperatures and densities achieved in these core-collapse models span several of the distinct nucleosynthesis regions we identify, resulting in different trends in the 44Ti and 56Ni yields for different mass elements. The 44Ti and 56Ni mass fraction profiles from the exponential and power-law profiles generally explain the tendencies of the post-processed yields, depending on which regions are traversed by the model. We find that integrated yields of 44Ti and 56Ni from the exponential and power-law trajectories are generally within a factor two or less of the post-process yields. We also analyze the influence of specific nuclear reactions on the 44Ti and 56Ni abundance evolution. Reactions that affect all yields globally are the 3$\alpha$, p($e^{-}, \nu_e$)n and n($e^{+},\overline{\nu_e}$)p. The rest of the reactions are ranked according to their degree of impact on the synthesis of 44Ti. The primary ones include 44Ti($\alpha,p$)47V, 40Ca($\alpha,\gamma$)44Ti, 45V($p,\gamma$)46Cr, 40Ca($\alpha,p$)43Sc, 17F($\alpha,p$))20Ne, 21Na($\alpha,p$))24Mg, 41Sc($p,\gamma$))42Ti, 43Sc($p,\gamma$))44Ti, 44Ti($p,\gamma$))45V, and 57Ni($p,\gamma$))58Cu, along with numerous weak reactions. Our analysis suggests that not all 44Ti need to be produced in an α-rich freeze-out in core-collapse events, and that reaction rate equilibria in combination with timescale effects for the expansion profile may account for the paucity of 44Ti observed in supernova remnants.

The data for the contour plots along with source code to interpolate within the 3D data cube of initial temperature, density, electron fraction Ye are in interpolate_abundances.tar.xz.

image image

Contraints on the progenitor of Cassiopeia A (2006)
In this article we compare a suite of three-dimensional explosion calculations and stellar models incorporating advanced physics with observational constraints on the progenitor of Cassiopeia A. We consider binary and single stars from 16 to 40 M with a range of explosion energies and geometries. The parameter space allowed by observations of nitrogen-rich high-velocity ejecta, ejecta mass, compact remnant mass, and 44Ti and 56Ni abundances individually and as an ensemble is considered. A progenitor of 15-25 M that loses its hydrogen envelope to a binary interaction and undergoes an energetic explosion can match all the observational constraints.

44Ti and 60Co - 1996
In this article, we explore the production of the radioactive isotopes 44Ti and 60Co in all types of supernovae is examined and compared to observational constraints including Galactic γ-ray surveys, measurements of the diffuse 511 keV radiation, γ-ray observations of Cas A, the light curve of SN 1987A, and isotopic anomalies found in silicon carbide grains in meteorites.

The (revised) line flux from $^{44}$Ti decay in the Cas A supernova remnant reported by COMPTEL on the Compton Gamma Ray Observatory is near the upper bound expected from our models. The necessary concurrent ejection of $^{56}$Ni would also imply that Cas A was a brighter supernova than previously thought unless extinction in the intervening matter was very large. Thus, if confirmed, the reported amount of $^{44}$Ti in Cas A provides very interesting constraints on both the supernova environment and its mechanism. The abundances of $^{44}$Ti and $^{60}$Co ejected by Type II supernovae are such that gamma-radiation from $^{44}$Ti decay SN 1987A could be detected by a future generation of gamma- ray telescopes, and that the decay of $^{60}$Co might provide an interesting contribution to the late-time light curve of SN 1987A and other core collapse supernovae. To produce the solar $^{44}$Ca abundance and satisfy all the observational constraints, nature may prefer at least the occasional explosion of sub-Chandrasekhar mass white dwarfs as Type Ia supernovae. Depending on the escape fraction of positrons due to $^{56}$Co made in all kinds of Type Ia supernovae, a significant fraction of the steady state diffuse 511 keV emission may arise from the annihilation of positrons produced during the decay of $^{44}$Ti to $^{44}$Ca. The Ca and Ti isotopic anomalies in presolar grains confirm the production of $^{44}$Ti in supernovae and that extensive mixing between zones has occurred, but a quantitative model for this mixing is presently lacking.

image image


AMS of 44Ti